Why a market cannot be changed
If someone can change the terms of a live market, that power exists. The design removes it instead of guarding it.
- Published
- Tags
- design, immutability
- Length
- 224 words
Most lending protocols are run as a single product with a governance process attached. Somebody decides which assets are listed. Somebody decides the borrowing limits. Somebody decides which price source counts. When conditions change, somebody votes.
That has a cost. If a party can change the terms of a live market, that power exists, and sooner or later someone will want to use it or take it.
Removing the power instead of guarding it
The answer in this design is not a better committee or a longer delay. Once a market exists, nothing about its terms can be changed by anyone.
| Term | After creation |
|---|---|
| Price source | Frozen |
| Interest rate curve | Frozen |
| Borrowing and liquidation limits | Frozen |
Nobody can rewrite a live market, and nobody can pause its withdrawals.
The part that is inconvenient
Because nothing can be edited, using different terms means creating a new market. People move across if they want to. The old market keeps the terms its lenders accepted.
That is inconvenient, slightly. It is also the only version in which “cannot be changed” means anything.
What it does not do
A market created with poor terms keeps them. Nobody can fix it either. That is the cost of the same property.
And rules that cannot be changed cannot create liquidity. A withdrawal still needs cash to be in the market.